The Critical Question of First Nations National Sovereignty Today

The First Nations, Inuit and Metis Peoples of Turtle Island (Canada), have been in tension with the Governments of Canada for many years, struggling to build Nation-to-Nation relationships, calling for respect for their sovereignty as Nations and for the Treaties signed between them.

This can now be seen in the struggle between Federal and Provincial demands for pipelines to the west coast vs. First Nations calling for respect of their rights to “free, prior and informed consent”;  the tension between Federal and Provincial desire to open up the “Ring of Fire” Region of northern Ontario to mining vs. First Nations demanding respect for their Treaty 9 rights;  the conflict between the Government of Nova Scotia which passed legislation in 2025 to lift the decades-long ban on hydraulic fracturing for onshore gas so as to re-initiate exploration, vs. the Assembly of Nova Scotia Mi’kmac Chiefs who oppose this, and intend to file an injunction against the law lifting the ban on uranium mining and exploration, and ending a moratorium on fracking. They raise the issue of lack of consultation concerning unceded and traditional Mi’kmac territory.

As First Nations, Inuit, and Metis peoples listen to the present debates about the place of sovereignty in the International scene, they feel all the more the great need to raise their voices concerning the essential need for Nation- to -Nation dialogue and decision-making,  their sovereign rights as Nations, and their Treaty Rights. Despite the Calls to Action of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission, and Canada’s finally assenting to  the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP),  the First Nations of Treaty 9 Territory find themselves once again facing the Government of Ontario in a difficult Court Case to defend their rights. ( Insert photo of “Allies of Treaty 9 Defenders” )

As is often the case, the issue is availability of natural resources. The “Plaintiff Nations” in this Court Case state that, for over a century, settler governments have forcefully moved into the lands of Treaty 9 territory, exploiting the resources, and leaving the First Nations impoverished. At present the Government of Ontario is wanting to fast-track industrial development on Indigenous lands, push for permits to mine, deforest, build roads, and dam rivers without the “free, prior and informed consent” of the Indigenous Nations.  This territory holds the coveted essential minerals for the advancing of technology, and batteries for electric cars.

 As a resident of Toronto, I have been shocked at the advertisements from the Government of Ontario placed strategically on public transit, picturing the potential jobs which will be available very soon in the Ring of Fire region. All of this is particularly  sensitive to me as I worked with Cree Nations in the Ring of Fire region several years ago, and experienced, at that time, many injustices and abuses to the people by Federal and Provincial Governments.

The present Coalition of nine First Nations have had enough! They are pushing back in Court to seek co-jurisdiction in Treaty No.9 Territory, giving them greater decision-making power over resource extraction projects on their lands, only after receiving “free, prior, and informed consent” from the Nations. Based on their treaty rights, they are aiming to protect the largest intact boreal forest in the world, a carbon storehouse as globally significant as the Amazon rainforest. In the Campaign they have developed, they state that there must be protection of the Breathing Lands.

Sitting in the Court House on December 18, I listened to the “Crown”, represented by the Provincial lawyer, plead his case  that the existing legal documents on the rights of Indigenous Peoples did not, in fact, give them the right to override the needs and intentions of the Government of Ontario. At the end of the day, the cases of both sides had not yet been fully heard, and the Court adjourned without a decision made.

Advocacy for the sovereign rights of these Nations must continue for the sake of he Breathing Lands they have cared for, and protected, since time immemorial.

Peace,

Mary-Ellen